From our location data

Per-pound vs. per-box: doing the math

Twenty locations in our records price shredding by the box instead of the pound. With the box weights those same providers publish, the two systems can finally be compared.

Our main guide warns against assuming a weight per box to convert between pricing systems. This article follows that rule strictly: every conversion below uses only a weight or a capacity the provider itself publishes in the same record. Where a provider publishes no weight, we do not convert its price.

The flat tote

Shred-it: $75 a tote, in 13 cities at once

Thirteen of our 179 records are Shred-it drop-off locations, from Phoenix to Honolulu, and every one publishes the identical per-box price: $75 per 96-gallon tote, with the tote defined in the same record as holding 10–12 letter-size boxes. That definition is all the math needs. At 12 boxes, the tote works out to $6.25 per box; at 10 boxes, $7.50 per box. However full you pack it, the published per-box cost of the tote system lands in that $6.25–$7.50 band — and the records also note that these locations take prepay online drop-off and list hard-drive destruction as a separate service, so the $75 is a paper price, not an everything price.

The tote's weakness is the mirror of its strength: it is one flat price regardless of whether your load fills it. The per-box records below show what smaller, box-at-a-time pricing looks like when a load is one or two boxes rather than ten.

Single boxes, converted

Two boxes that publish their own weights

Secure On-Site Shredding in the Dallas–Fort Worth metro publishes $20 per banker's box for drop-off, and defines that box in the same record as 1.5 cubic feet and approximately 30 pounds. Dividing its own numbers gives an effective rate of about $0.67 per pound — a third below the $1.00 median per-pound price across our 161 priced locations. Shred Bull in Los Angeles publishes $10 per standard banker box at its drop-off locations, with the box described as about 25 pounds: an effective $0.40 per pound, equal to the cheapest per-pound price published anywhere in our records.

Two more records show the structured versions of box pricing. Altitude DocuShred in Denver publishes a $45 minimum covering up to 5 standard banker's boxes, with additional standard boxes at $8 and large boxes at $10 — so a 5-box load is $9 per box, and every box after the fifth is cheaper than the boxes inside the minimum. Beacon Secure in Tucson publishes $45 flat for up to 100 pounds of walk-in paper, with additional pounds over 100 at $0.30 per pound: at exactly 100 pounds that is an effective $0.45 per pound, and the rate only falls from there. Paper Tiger Document Solutions in Chicago publishes the widest spread in a single record: $35 for the first 300 pounds on weekday drop-off, and $3 per copy-paper-size box at its Saturday Shred Fest.

What to check

  • Whether the box price defines the box — size, fullness, or weight.
  • Whether a minimum covers your first boxes before the per-box rate starts.
  • Whether hard drives and media are priced separately from paper.
  • Whether the published price is per box, per tote, or per visit.

Both prices at once

When one location publishes both systems

The most instructive record in our data belongs to Sip & Ship in Seattle, which publishes both prices: $2.85 per pound and $25 per banker's box. No outside assumption is needed to find the crossover — dividing its box price by its pound price, the box rate wins for any box heavier than about 8.8 pounds, and the pound rate wins below that. Neighborhood Parcel in Boston publishes the same dual structure in the other direction: $0.99 per pound, plus per-box pricing of $15 per small box and $20 per large box for orders of 10 or more boxes. Dual-published records like these are the exception — only a handful of our 179 locations publish both systems — but they prove the point of this article: per-box pricing is not automatically cheaper or dearer. It depends on the weight in your box, and the honest conversions, using the providers' own published weights, put converted box prices at $0.40–$0.67 per pound against a $1.00 per-pound median. For a full box, the box price usually wins; for a half-empty one, weigh it instead. Confirm the current price and box definition with the location before you go — published terms change.

Compare published shredding prices

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Is per-box shredding cheaper than per-pound?

In the records that publish a box weight, yes for a full box: Secure On-Site Shredding's $20 box at about 30 pounds converts to roughly $0.67 per pound, and Shred Bull's $10 box at about 25 pounds to $0.40 per pound, against a $1.00 median per-pound price. A partly filled box reverses the comparison.

How much is a Shred-it tote in your records?

All 13 Shred-it locations in our records publish $75 per 96-gallon tote, defined as holding 10–12 letter-size boxes — $6.25 to $7.50 per box depending on how many boxes the tote holds.

Why don't you convert every per-box price?

Because a conversion needs a weight, and we only use weights the provider itself publishes in the same record. Twenty of our 179 locations publish per-box terms; only some publish a box weight or capacity alongside the price.